Which Motley Fool Service Is The Best? – A Complete Guide

by | May 14, 2021 | Investing

The Motley Fool is one of the most popular stock picking services and financial advice websites. The platform gained fame in the investing community for its flagship Stock Advisor newsletter, which has outperformed the S&P 500 by a factor of nearly five since its inception in 2002.

However, there’s more to the Motley Fool than just Stock Advisor. In this article, we’ll help you decide which Motley Fool service is the best tool to invest with.

What is the Motley Fool?

The Motley Fool is an investment platform created by Tom and David Gardner in 1993. The company was designed to offer advice and stock picks for self-driven investors, and originally took a contrarian view to Wall Street orthodoxy.

However, over time, the Motley Fool became so popular that it is essentially a mainstay of financial news. The Stock Advisor newsletter alone has more than 700,000 subscribers and new stock picks typically jump by around 5%.

Today, the Motley Fool offers a mix of subscription-based stock picking services, educational guides for investing and retirement, and stock news and analysis. The site continues to be run by the Gardner brothers, although David Gardner recently announced his retirement from stock picking.

Motley Fool - Homepage

What Types of Services Does the Motley Fool Offer?

The Motley Fool’s premium service offerings revolve around stock picking. In addition to the flagship Stock Advisor service, the company has dozens of different stock picking services that focus on different thematic areas – like AI, cannabis, and fintech – as well as different investing strategies.

Most of the Motley Fool’s newsletters focus on stocks, but the company does have some services that focus on alternative investments. For example, the Total Income newsletter includes bonds and real estate investments and the Options newsletter focuses on options trading.

What Makes for a Good Service?

There are a couple things to consider when evaluating the Motley Fool’s stock picking services.

First, whatever service you pick should match your investment style. If you want to aggressively invest in growth stocks, then choosing a newsletter that focuses on income investments or low-volatility stocks doesn’t make much sense. Since the Motley Fool has such a wide range of newsletters, it shouldn’t be hard to find one that matches your style.

Second, the service you choose needs to be easy to use. Part of what makes Stock Advisor so popular is that it includes just two picks per month and a simple buy recommendation. More complicated newsletters are okay, but they need to be simple enough that you’ll actually act on the recommendations in a timely manner.

Finally, and most important, a stock picking service needs to have a history of strong performance. The Motley Fool’s top newsletters, including Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers, have outperformed the S&P 500 by several-fold since they began. However, not every Motley Fool newsletter has done so well. Be sure to look closely at the total return of the newsletter you’re interested in and how it’s performed in recent years.

What is the Best Motley Fool Service?

With all that in mind, what’s the best Motley Fool newsletter? We’ll highlight a few Motley Fool services that we think stand out.

Stock Advisor – Best Overall

There’s a reason Stock Advisor has garnered over 700,000 subscribers and has run continuously for 19 years. It’s simply the best newsletter the Motley Fool has to offer and one of the top stock picking services available today.

Motley Fool - Stock Advisor

The Motley Fool’s flagship service has generated a return of 569% since 2002 compared to just 131% for the S&P 500. That’s thanks in part to picks like Amazon (+21,000%) and Netflix (+23,000%). It’s also incredibly cheap at just $199 per year.

Stock Advisor is simple to follow since there’s just two recommendations a month. The service also comes with five ‘Best Buy’ picks per month, which encourage you to double down on stocks already in the portfolio, and a beginner portfolio to help you get started. Just note that Stock Advisor tends to focus on growth stocks, so it often recommends tech companies and other relatively risky stocks.

Get 50% OFF Your First Year Of Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Rule Breakers – Best for Growth Stocks & Expanding Your Portfolio

Rule Breakers is similar to Stock Advisor, except that it’s run solely by David Gardner and his team (Stock Advisor includes both David and Tom Gardner). Since its start in 2003, the portfolio has returned 319% compared to 113% for the S&P 500. Rule Breakers is more expensive than Stock Advisor at $299 per year, but it’s still fairly inexpensive given how impressive the returns have been.

Motley Fool - Rule Breakers

Rule Breakers differs from Stock Advisor in that it focuses almost exclusively on explosive growth stocks. So, the service is looking specifically for home runs instead of just strong picks. It’s best suited for investors who already have a base portfolio and want to add in some riskier stock picks. It’s also a good option if you already use Stock Advisor and want more picks each month. 

Get 50% OFF Your First Year Of Motley Fool Rule Breakers

Options – Best for Options Trading

As the name suggests, the Motley Fool’s Options trading service is designed specifically for options traders. The service advertises a profitability rate of 85% and builds off of the picks recommended by other Motley Fool services. Most of the strategies that the Options service uses are relatively simple to keep complexity to a minimum. 

Motley Fool - Options

Options is one of the Motley Fool’s more expensive services, at $999 per year. In addition to options ideas, you get access to the Motley Fool’s Options University, an educational hub for new options traders.

Get $100 OFF Motley Fool Options

Everlasting Portfolio – Best for Long-term Traders with Large Accounts

The Everlasting Portfolio service is run by Tom Gardner and his team of analysts. The portfolio focuses on stocks that Tom considers the “best of the best” in the market today and are the only stocks that Tom personally owns. The portfolio is also backed with $15 million of the Motley Fool’s investable assets.

Motley Fool - Everlasting Portfolio

This service has performed incredibly well. Since launching in 2012, it’s up more than 550%. All of the picks are designed to be held for at least 5 years, so this service is best for investors with a very long time horizon. It’s also priced at $2,999 per year, so it makes the most sense if you have a large pool of money to invest.

Get The BEST Deal On Motley Fool Everlasting Portfolio

Conclusion: Motley Fool Services

The Motley Fool is one of the most popular and successful stock picking companies in the world. While the platform is best known for its flagship Stock Advisor newsletter, services like Rule Breakers, Options, and Everlasting Portfolio are also worth a look. The Motley Fool has dozens of stock picking services, so you can easily find one that matches your investing style and goals.

<span style="font-size:12px;font-weight:500">Author</span><br><a href="https://wealthpursuits.com/author/kevin/" target="_self">Kevin</a>


Kevin is an ambitious entrepreneur that is obsessed with all things related to finance. From a young age, Kevin has always been involved with side hustles ranging from online selling to freelance work. Over the years, Kevin graduated from side hustles and started launching multiple online and offline businesses. Kevin is a serial entrepreneur who loves starting new businesses and exploring all things related to business and finance. He is constantly looking for new ways to save money, invest money, and create income streams.

Related Content:

What Is The Motley Fool? – Should You Use These Services?

What Is The Motley Fool? – Should You Use These Services?

The number of personal finance websites and services that are out there feels almost limitless. Even if you focus on one top like investment advice, a Google search will have overwhelming results. Knowing which financial services company to trust is important. Motley...

Tax-Free Investments – No Taxes, No Problems

Tax-Free Investments – No Taxes, No Problems

Let's be honest. While we don't like paying taxes, we pay them anyway. If we kept our money instead, it would lead to even bigger problems. The Internal Revenue Service isn't a friend to those who try to skip out on paying their taxes. It is possible, though, to delay...

Best Stock Market Newsletters – Our Top 6 Picks You Should Try

Best Stock Market Newsletters – Our Top 6 Picks You Should Try

If you prefer having control of your investing strategy or simply want to know what's happening in the financial markets, there is a lot to keep up with. Few of us have the time to read the Wall Street Journal every day so we know the latest news. Blog articles,...

Charlie Munger Investment Advice – 10 Actionable Tips

Charlie Munger Investment Advice – 10 Actionable Tips

Charlie Munger is the business partner of Warren Buffett and the vice-chairman of Berkshire Hathaway. Munger’s investment philosophy closely mirrors that of Buffett – he believes in investing in strong businesses with a long-term mindset. In this article, we’ll take a...

Jack Bogle Investment Advice – His Top 10 Philosophies

Jack Bogle Investment Advice – His Top 10 Philosophies

John C. ‘Jack’ Bogle was the founder of the investment firm Vanguard and is widely regarded as the father of modern index funds. He spent decades railing against active investing in general and high-fee mutual funds in particular. In this article, we’ll take a look at...

Jim Cramer Investment Advice – 10 Top Recommendations

Jim Cramer Investment Advice – 10 Top Recommendations

Jim Cramer, best known as the host of the CNBC show Mad Money, has made a career out of offering investment advice and stock picks. In this guide, we’ll take a look at 10 of Jim Cramer’s top pieces of investment advice that you can use to improve your performance in...

Dave Ramsey Investment Advice – Top 10 Finance Tips

Dave Ramsey Investment Advice – Top 10 Finance Tips

Dave Ramsey is a well-known financial guru who has spent decades helping individuals manage their finances and invest for retirement. In this guide, we’ll look at the top 10 Dave Ramsey investment advice tips for how you can manage your money and invest for the...